Mac's Stuffed Cookies

How to Warm a Stuffed Cookie for a Gooey Centre

A Classic Melt stuffed cookie in its foil cup, ready to warm

A stuffed cookie is good straight from the box, but a few seconds of warmth turns it into something else: the filling softens, the chocolate melts and the middle goes gooey again. Here is how to do it.

The quick way: microwave

  1. Take the cookie out of the foil cup or tin. Metal must never go in the microwave.
  2. Put it on a plate.
  3. Microwave for 10 to 15 seconds. Start with 10; you can always add a few more.
  4. Let it sit for 30 seconds, then break it open.

Every microwave is different, so go gently. Too long and the cookie turns tough as it cools.

The best way: oven

  1. Heat the oven to 160°C.
  2. Put the cookie on a tray lined with baking paper.
  3. Warm it for about 5 minutes.

The oven takes longer but gives the best result: crisp edges, a soft, warm centre and melting chocolate on top. It is the way to go if you are warming a few at once, or the whole Loaded Tin (take the cookies out of the tin first).

A word of care

The filling gets hotter than the cookie around it. Let it rest for a moment before the first bite, especially for kids.

How to store your cookies

  • They are best within 2 weeks of the baking date.
  • Keep them in an airtight container at room temperature, out of the sun.
  • In the Cookie Box, each cookie is sealed in its own bag, so you can open one at a time.
  • There is no need to refrigerate them, and the fridge tends to dry cookies out. A few seconds of warmth brings back the soft centre.

Make it a dessert

  • Warm a cookie and add a scoop of vanilla ice cream on top.
  • Break a warm Pistachio Dream over a bowl of ice cream.
  • Put the whole warmed Loaded Tin cookies in the middle of the table and let everyone tear off a piece.

Ready for a warm cookie?

Build your own at Mac's Stuffed Cookies, or read what makes a stuffed cookie.

Questions

How long do I microwave a stuffed cookie?

About 10 to 15 seconds. Take it out of the foil cup or tin first, because metal cannot go in the microwave.

Can I warm a stuffed cookie in the oven?

Yes. About 5 minutes at 160°C on a tray lined with baking paper gives a crisp edge and a soft centre.

How should I store stuffed cookies?

In an airtight container at room temperature, away from the sun. The Cookie Box keeps each cookie in its own sealed bag.

Big, thick, stuffed cookies, built your way.

Build your cookies →

More from the blog