Mac's Stuffed Cookies

What Is a Stuffed Cookie? Big, Thick Cookies Explained

The Classic Melt: a big, thick golden stuffed cookie with milk chocolate on top

If you have seen a cookie on Instagram that looks more like a small cake, broken open with a river of Nutella running out of the middle, you have seen a stuffed cookie. Here is what makes one, and why they are worth the hype.

A stuffed cookie in one sentence

A stuffed cookie is a big, thick, chunky cookie with a soft filling baked right into the centre, finished with a topping on the outside.

How it differs from a normal cookie

  • Size: a normal cookie is a snack; a stuffed cookie is about the size of your palm and properly thick.
  • Texture: crisp, crackly edges and a soft, almost underbaked middle, rather than an even crunch all the way through.
  • The filling: this is the big one. A ball of filling such as Nutella, Biscoff spread or pistachio cream is wrapped in the dough before baking, so it stays soft and gooey inside.
  • The topping: chunks of chocolate, broken biscuits, chopped pistachios or a drizzle, piled on top.

Where the style comes from

Big, thick cookies became famous in New York bakeries, where people queue for cookies that are closer to a scone in height than a biscuit. The stuffed version adds a filling in the middle, and it has taken off in Australia over the last few years.

How we make ours

Every Mac's Stuffed Cookie starts with three choices:

  • The dough: golden butter, double chocolate or red velvet
  • The filling inside: Nutella, Biscoff spread, pistachio cream, cookies and cream, white chocolate cream, salted caramel or dark chocolate ganache
  • The topping: from milk chocolate chunks and broken biscuits to premium toppings like Belgian chocolate shards with edible gold

The filling is frozen into a small disc first, so it stays in the centre while the cookie bakes around it. That is how you get a thick cookie with a soft, gooey middle instead of a flat one with the filling leaking out.

Our six signature stuffed cookies

  • The Classic Melt: golden dough, Nutella filling, milk chocolate
  • Cookies & Cream: double chocolate dough, cookies and cream filling, biscuit chunks
  • Caramel Biscuit: golden dough, Biscoff filling, caramel biscuit chunks
  • Velvet Affair: red velvet dough, white chocolate inside and out
  • Pistachio Dream: golden dough, pistachio cream filling, chopped pistachios
  • Midnight Crinkle: black cocoa dough dusted with icing sugar, ganache centre

How to eat one

Warm it for a few seconds so the middle goes gooey again (see how to warm a stuffed cookie), then break it in half. One cookie is plenty for most people, and perfect for sharing.

Try one

Build your own at Mac's Stuffed Cookies: a single cookie in a foil cup, six baked together in the Loaded Tin, or six wrapped cookies in the Cookie Box, posted anywhere in Australia.

Questions

What is the difference between a stuffed cookie and a normal cookie?

A stuffed cookie is much bigger and thicker, and it has a soft filling such as Nutella, Biscoff or pistachio cream baked into the middle. A normal cookie is thinner and has no filling.

Are stuffed cookies the same as New York cookies?

They are related. New York style cookies are big, thick and chunky; a stuffed cookie takes that style and adds a filling in the centre.

How big is a stuffed cookie?

Ours are about the size of your palm and thick and domed. A foil cup cookie is about 180 to 200 grams.

Big, thick, stuffed cookies, built your way.

Build your cookies →

More from the blog